The inability of sole proprietors to reserve employees appears to be discrimination based on business form, according to Oleksandr Chumak, president of the Association of Private Employers.
Commenting on remarks made by Deputy Minister of Economy and Environment Yegor Grygorenko at the “Dialogue Between Government, Civil Society, and Business” forum on November 18 regarding the lack of consensus on formalizing at least some sole proprietorships—noting that, for now, “one-third of sole proprietorships are not quite sole proprietorships”— Chumak emphasized that arguments about the “fragmentation” of businesses or registering employees as entrepreneurs do not explain the situation of specific employers who officially hire people and fulfill orders, particularly for the maintenance of municipal equipment.
The association’s chairman also cited the example of two workshops with identical working conditions, salaries, and importance to the community, noting that a limited liability company (LLC) can qualify for “critically important” status, whereas a sole proprietorship, under similar conditions, is denied that opportunity.
“To me, this looks like discrimination based on the form of business organization. And I see echoes here of the old Soviet attitude toward entrepreneurs. Back then, it was easy to label someone who worked for themselves a ‘huckster’ or ‘speculator.’ Today, all it takes is to say ‘not quite a sole proprietor’—and an entrepreneur who has come with a specific question about an employee is already forced to explain that he is a ‘real’ one,” Chumak noted.
He also called for employers, regardless of their business structure, to be given the opportunity to undergo the same verification process based on established criteria and for public communication with entrepreneurs to be made more friendly.
As previously reported, Minister of Economy and Environment Oleksandr Kravchenko stated in November, following a regular meeting of the Presidential Council for Entrepreneurship Support, that the ministry is working to simplify the procedures for confirming critical status through the Coordination Center and to resolve technical issues with reservations via “Diyu.” In addition, in collaboration with the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Digital Transformation, proposals from the business community regarding greater predictability in the reservation mechanism will be reviewed.
Earlier, on October 23, the Cabinet of Ministers completed the implementation of changes to the reservation system, decoupling the criticality of enterprises from economic indicators and updating sectoral and regional criteria. A Coordination Center was also established to organize the reservation of conscripts during periods of mobilization and martial law, and the maximum reservation rate for the energy sector and the defense industry was reduced from 100% to 95%, with the option to apply to the Coordination Center to increase the quota. The government also announced a mechanism for 100-percent reservation, contingent upon fulfilling the mobilization obligation regarding the regular voluntary enlistment of employees into military service, which is currently under development.
Despite these changes, there is no provision for reserving employees or individual entrepreneurs (FOPs) themselves.
During the forum, Deputy Minister of Economy and Environment Yegor Grygorenko noted that such proposals had been put forward previously.
“It seems to me that… as long as one-third of our sole proprietors aren’t really sole proprietors, and as long as we don’t resolve this issue—including through the Labor Code, which it would be good to adopt—we won’t reach a consensus on sole proprietors here. That’s the honest answer, but that’s how it is,” said the deputy head of the Ministry of Economy.
BUSINESS, employer, mobilization, reservations, sole proprietors